tungwaiyip.info

home

about me

links

Blog

< October 2011 >
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
       1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031     

past articles »

Click for San Francisco, California Forecast

San Francisco, USA

 

Ranked Choice Voting Is Great - the Problem Is the Commentators

I'm disappointed to see another article from Chronicle to decry Ranked-choice voting complicates S.F. mayor's race. What is it so complicated about RCV? It is too complicated for voters? for candidates? or for commentators?

Let set the record straight. RCV is very simple for voters. You put in your ranked choice of number 1, number 2 and number 3 candidates. This is as straight forward as it can be. We often make similar choices in other siutation in life. That's no justified reason to call it complicated.

How the winner is decided may need more explanation. But this should not affect how they vote. A lot of voters may not know the exact detail of US presidential election either or to be able to explain why a candidate who gets the most vote do may necessary wins. Nevertheless this hardly become a issue for voters. It is more a problem for the election campaign for strategizing.

Still I want to bust the myth the RCV is hard to understand. It is simply a tournament. In each round the weakest candidates is eliminated. Whose vote is then assigned to the next ranked candidates if any is left on a ballot. The tournament keep running until a winner with the majority vote is found. Even last year's epic 21 candidates races in district 10 can be followed with a well organized chart. The old run off election system can be understand as a tournament with two rounds at most. With the first round eliminated everyone but the top two candidates.

RCV has greater stake for candidates who need to use perhaps a different strategy. The old way is just to admonish your opponents. Negative campaigns, though despised by voters, are found to be effective. In RCV they have to rely less on admonishing the opponents and to appeal to a large base of voters instead. In many ways, this is one of biggest improvement RCV brings.

The article cites the shocking defeat of Don Perata in Oakland's mayoral race. Don Perata does not understand RCV. That's one thing the article and I agree. I think Don Perata is a sad sad example. It is not because he lost the race, which is fair and square. It is sad because we elect officials precisely to understand and make decision on complex issues that we ordinary citizens do not have enough expertise or diligence. That's the essence of representative democracy. If Don Perata do no understand a simple game like RCV, how can we trust him with big issues like balancing budget, which is infinitely more complex?

The journalists do not help either. Instead of writing about many great improvement under RCV, they often throw doubt on the system. One issue they brought up is the election becomes a more unpredictable system. I agree. I think in many ways this is like saying the stock market is an unpredictable system. This is the nature of having a lot of individuals each making their own choice. The result is going to be unpredictable. When the "leading" candidate Don Perata loses to Jean Quan, it shocks a lot of commentators. Similarly a lot of times stock trend defies the prediction of "expert" analysts. Rather than doubting the market, perhaps we should be more humble in our knowledge and to re-examine how our prediction go wrong instead.

2011.10.23 [] - comments

 

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

past articles »

 

BBC News

 

Turkey Syria offensive: Trump lifts Turkey sanctions after deal (23 Oct 2019)

 

Essex lorry deaths: Work starts to identify 39 bodies (23 Oct 2019)

 

'I came to the UK hiding inside a lorry' (23 Oct 2019)

 

Google claims 'quantum supremacy' for computer (23 Oct 2019)

 

Ellie Goulding on climate change: 'The backlash grows ever uglier' (23 Oct 2019)

 

Thai king fires officials for 'extremely evil' conduct (23 Oct 2019)

 

Facebook's Zuckerberg grilled over Libra currency plan (23 Oct 2019)

 

Scientist gets £2m decades after he invented diabetes test (23 Oct 2019)

 

Leader of South Africa's largest opposition party quits (23 Oct 2019)

 

Canada election: PM Trudeau rules out coalition after election (23 Oct 2019)

more »

 

SF Gate

 

Ship traffic, October 24 (23 Oct 2019)

 

WeWork accepts lifeline from SoftBank (22 Oct 2019)

 

Ship traffic, October 23 (22 Oct 2019)

 

Facebook lays on the charm for Libra cryptocurrency plan (21 Oct 2019)

 

Exxon trial probes how oil giant accounts for climate change (21 Oct 2019)

 

A 6-year-old asks why there are no female toy soldiers. Now there will be (21 Oct 2019)

more »


Site feed Updated: 2019-Oct-23 15:00