tungwaiyip.info

home

about me

links

Blog

< March 2009 >
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 91011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031    

past articles »

Click for San Francisco, California Forecast

San Francisco, USA

 

Movie Review - El Norte

El Norte

El Norte (1983)
Director: Gregory Nava

El Norte is a story about two indigenous Guatemalan brother and sister, fleeing from the civil strife from their village, embarked on a perilous journey for a new life in the United States, which is simply referred as El Norte (the north) by the people. As this title has suggested, it is a story seen entirely from the point of view of the immigrants. For them U.S. is the land of legendary riches. Immigration laws are really challenges they have to workaround. But when they have arrived, the reality is a lot harder than they have imagined. They find their prospect limited to menial labor, and a life under the shadow of illegal status with a constant threat of deportation.

This is the third time I have seen this movie over the course of 20 years. Each time it is an emotional experience. And each time I see something new. This first time was in Hong Kong when I was in school. I can quickly connect the film into the movement of illegal immigrants from China to Hong Kong that we have experienced first hand. The second time I become aware of the politics in Guatemala that made life so untenable in their villages, which I have managed to miss entirely in the first viewing. Also by that time I am living in US myself and I can see the depiction of their life is very realistic.

On my third viewing, it is the film's 25th anniversary already. Guatemala has become more peaceful since then. But the illegal immigration issue in the US is more intense than ever. Somehow I see something new this time, that El Norte is a so much better place!

Seriously, this may not be what the director has in mind when he made the film. But I see the people being so much nicer to each other. Enrique was a nobody. But when he poured coffee for the rich people, the rich people said "thank you" to him! Back home they are merely despised Indians. And the military men hunted them down like animals. Here they are actually getting some respect. When Rosa refused to go to the hospital because she said she is afraid of the government, it is not only because of her immigration status. Her reaction can only be understood because she came from a society where more often than not, the government is working against the people instead of working for the people. But here, despite of her legal status, she will receive treatment from the hospital.

By calling it better I don't mean this is a rich land with flush toilet and where even the poorest own a car, as it was alleged by some villagers. It is that I truly see it as a land of opportunities. I must have somehow enlightened by Jane Jacob's depiction on how a city works. I see vibrant economy, upward mobility and training freely available to help people succeed. When Enrique was promoted from busboy to waiter, we are so proud of him. It is not that waiter is a particularly promising career. We are proud of him because we see he has grown, because he has learned enough English in just a short time and because he was recognized for his merit. Make no mistake, they are living an unglamorous life at the bottom of the social ladder. But this is more of a problem only if we judge them by gringo standard. Should we consider where they have come from, a different picture will emerge. This is a society that provides them basic security, justice and endless opportunities. All these are lacking from their village.

My new realization makes me appreciate US more and perhaps diluted the film's tragic quality a bit. Nevertheless it is still an authentic and humanistic story. I am looking forward for my fourth viewing soon.

2009.03.20 [] - comments

 

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

past articles »

 

BBC News

 

Pope Francis condemns child sex abuse and Church cover-ups (20 Aug 2018)

 

Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani defends 'truth isn't truth' remark (20 Aug 2018)

 

Italy bridge collapse: CCTV shows moment disaster struck (20 Aug 2018)

 

Measles cases hit record high in Europe (20 Aug 2018)

 

Korea reunion: Mother and son reunite after 67 years (20 Aug 2018)

 

Asia Argento 'accused of sexual assault' (20 Aug 2018)

 

Áurea Vázquez Rijos: Beauty queen on trial for husband's murder (20 Aug 2018)

 

Chechen police kill four teenage attackers (20 Aug 2018)

 

Gatwick flight information screens fail (20 Aug 2018)

 

Trump aide 'fired over ties to white nationalist event' (20 Aug 2018)

more »

 

SF Gate

 

Economists say Trump’s tariffs are unfavorable for US growth (20 Aug 2018)

 

Ship traffic, August 21 (20 Aug 2018)

 

Big Tech is spending big in a decidedly old-school way (19 Aug 2018)

 

Smart doorbells to watch over your front stoop (19 Aug 2018)

 

A rising concern? After straws, balloons get more scrutiny (19 Aug 2018)

 

From Elon Musk interview: ‘not on weed’ and the ‘worst is yet to come’ (18 Aug 2018)

more »


Site feed Updated: 2018-Aug-20 15:00