The news of San Francisco building
a city-wide wireless network is getting a lot of attention these
days. Broadbandreports runs several stories on this. While
broadbandreports itself is a proponent of municipal broadband, I am
surprise that the news draw torrents of criticism from readers. Many
reject this because it is a 'liberal' thing. Other took the line of
incumbent telcos that existing access methods is preferable to a public
project.
While I think many posting are nothing but political fervent, I am
also disappointed that people do not see the potential of universal
connectivity as a big step forward (a departure from the usually
'hypish' technology sector). I have posted my reaction,
which I include here:
Reader's post
Disgusting
It is pathetic how the flaming Left in this country has
confused the term "right" and "entitlement." Sure, everyone has a
"right" to Wifi. There is nothing stopping you from working, earning
some money and buying the needed tools yourself. Its no different than
there being a right to free speech and free press. Does this mean the
government is required to provide you with the means to exercise those
rights? Of course not.
Some other posters here have mentioned guns. Under Mayor
Newsom's reasoning, the right to gun ownership requires that the
government give free guns out to everyone.
My response
There is nothing stopping you from working, earning some money and
buying the needed tools yourself.
True. There is also nothing to stop private entities to build
railroads and toll roads and then charge everyone a use fee either. Just
like what the country did a century ago. Do you find it disgusting that
the government took it upon themselves to build roads and offer it for
free to people?
Look there are no lack of proposals from commercial companies to
offer the service, apparently costing the city little. People get access
in the parks and schools and cafe and hopefully all pocket of households
that do not yet have access. I don't understand what the objection is.
Do you have a better proposal?
3G, if it is available at all, would cost a bundle. Imagine now that
there is universal wireless access. You go to a shop and look at an
item. You'll pull your PDA or cellphone and do a search on the UNC code.
Immediately it turns out a list of reviews, links to other outlets, and
recommendation for alternatives or accessories you'll need. You'd IM
your wife. Once she sees the picture she'd told you you got the wrong
stuff again! That's new commerce that will be enabled by universal
access! You'd bet Google is working on that already!
You'd think broadband report readers are a bunch of smart guys. But
when it comes to public project all the anti-government ideology would
just overcome their judgement. Guys I'm off to hack the next big thing
for the future of universal connectivity. Go on with your
anti-government bashing.
2005.10.04 [mobile, network, San Francisco] - comments (0)