tungwaiyip.info

home

about me

links

Blog

< November 2012 >
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
     1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930 

past articles »

Click for San Francisco, California Forecast

San Francisco, USA

 

San Francisco Should Adopt Simple Recount for D7 Election

News reports that the closely contested District 7 election recount could cost up to $200,000. Many RCV haters take this as another problem to attack RCV election.

But if you look closer at the result, a recount should not be more costly than a plurality voting election. The fact is this is a race between F.X. Crowley and Norman Yee. No other candidate come close. From the detail D7 Results Report we can see that the second runner up Michael Garcia was eliminate in round 5. His has 7473 vote, trailing the first runner up F.X. Crowley's 9709 vote by 30%. He could not have possibly make it to the last round. This mean the race is between F.X. Crowley and Norman Yee only. No other candidates will have nearly enough vote to make it to the final round.

In this case we can adopt a simple recount procedure. Instead of running a full ranking, we can accelerate this and eliminate all other candidates right away. If a vote has both Yee and Crowley on it, it should goes to the higher ranked candidate. If it has only Yee, irrespective what rank it is, it is a vote for Yee. And similarly a vote has only Crowley goes to him irrespective of what rank it is. If a vote that has neither Yee or Crowley it goes to the exhausted ballot bin. This allow us to do a quick recount without painstakingly ranking every choice. And the result will the same as doing the full ranking.

It may be too late for San Francisco to adopt a new recount procedure after the fact. But if both candidate agree this is a fair way to do it, I think they can push this as a preliminary recount procedure. The incremental cost of a simple recount should not be much higher compare to plurality voting. And this should help settle the doubt of the election result.

2012.11.27 comments

 

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

past articles »

 

BBC News

 

Dutch shooting: Utrecht police arrest suspect after three killed (18 Mar 2019)

 

Cyclone Idai: Mozambique president says 1,000 may have died (18 Mar 2019)

 

'No third Brexit vote without changes' (18 Mar 2019)

 

Three dead in record flooding in US Midwestern states (18 Mar 2019)

 

New Zealand shootings: Christchurch students perform Haka for victims (18 Mar 2019)

 

Italy's La Scala opera house to return Saudi millions (19 Mar 2019)

 

Yellow vest protests: Paris police sacked, rally bans planned (18 Mar 2019)

 

Rio state takes over running of Brazil's iconic Maracanã stadium (18 Mar 2019)

 

Armando, the 'Lewis Hamilton of pigeons' sells for record €1.25m (18 Mar 2019)

 

Russia human rights: Chechnya court jails Memorial activist (18 Mar 2019)

more »

 

SF Gate

 

Women in economics report rampant sexual assault and bias (18 Mar 2019)

 

The A-list heads to Apple as challenge to Netflix takes shape (18 Mar 2019)

 

Ship traffic, March 19 (18 Mar 2019)

 

Facebook’s messaging ambitions amount to much more than chat (17 Mar 2019)

 

A better way to break up big tech (17 Mar 2019)

 

Trump administration could hamper shift to more efficient light bulbs (17 Mar 2019)

more »


Site feed Updated: 2019-Mar-18 18:00