tungwaiyip.info

home

about me

links

Blog

< May 2006 >
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031   

past articles »

Click for San Francisco, California Forecast

San Francisco, USA

 

National Geographic - Guns, Germs and Steel

Yesterday I have watched the documentary Guns, Germs and Steel based on Jared Diamond's book of the same name. I have not read the book. But with Jared Diamond being the host himself this should be a good representation of his book.

He started off in Papua New Guinea. Stuck by the islanders' deprivation, he tried to explain why do the West prosper and why do other cultures remain impoverished. His theory is that geography (environment), guns, germs and steel (technology) are the major factors that set them apart. The documentary followed the development of civilization from hunter-gatherers to farmers. It brought us back to the fateful battle between Francisco Pizarro and the Inca Empire. Finally it looked at the challenges in Africa, the land where the human race is believed to be originated from.

His book has won a Pulitzer Prize and his theory is called ground breaking. Flattery comments notwithstanding everything he said has been studied in anthropology. While all of them have some degree of truth, there are many other important factors he simply ignored, like culture, politics, religion and non-military technology. Also his emphasis on the environmental factor just sound too deterministic. Interesting this exact critique has voiced in the documentary.

I find two big faults in his thesis. First he like to insert simple answers for big questions. Why do our civilization developed in such way? Answer: geography, guns, germs and steel. But in fact he has only downplayed many other important factors. On the other hand there are plenty of counter examples for everything he has said. For example, which success factor did Mongolian possess when their conquered much of Europe and Asia? What geography advantages does England has that led them to become a global empire? Why does Arab and Chinese, with civilization in the similar stage with European, did not set off to conquer the world? His answer is really a weak answer at best.

Secondly he has a dichotomy view on cultures as winners and losers. Lots of focus are put on warfare and military technologies (i.e. guns, germs and steel) Other world shaping forces such as trading are entirely ignored. I doubt such winner and loser view can explain the complexity of civilization. For example, throughout its history China repeatedly fell to the nomadic invaders from the North. Jared's theory would have concluded the nomads the winner and possess some advantage over the Chinese loser (though non of his 4 factors can really count here). The interesting thing is over time many invaders adopted chinese culture and assimilated into the host country. Winner and loser cannot really describe what has happened.

Just curious. Jared is certainly not the first anthropologist to pose a big theory. What makes his work so popular?

2006.05.25 [] - comments

 

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

past articles »

 

BBC News

 

Nxivm: Sex cult leader Raniere found guilty in New York (19 Jun 2019)

 

MH17: Four charged with shooting down plane over Ukraine (19 Jun 2019)

 

Rory Stewart out of race to be UK PM (19 Jun 2019)

 

Spy satellites reveal extent of Himalayan glacier loss (19 Jun 2019)

 

Slavery reparations hearing ignites fiery debate in Congress (19 Jun 2019)

 

Rugby-playing detective tackles intruder (19 Jun 2019)

 

Egypt Morsi TV gaffe puts spotlight on control of media (19 Jun 2019)

 

Manslaughter arrest over footballer Sala's death (19 Jun 2019)

 

Garissa University attack: Three convicted over Kenya massacre (19 Jun 2019)

 

Nicolas Sarkozy: Former French president loses bid to avoid bribery trial (19 Jun 2019)

more »

 

SF Gate

 

Desperation in France’s food delivery gig economy (18 Jun 2019)

 

The big question for the Fed this week: Did we make a mistake? (17 Jun 2019)

 

The US has its eye on Big Tech. Will criminal inquiries result? (17 Jun 2019)

 

The bias embedded in tech (17 Jun 2019)

 

Watch Tim Cook slam the tech industry in Stanford graduation commencement speech (17 Jun 2019)

 

Here’s what it’s like to work at Twitch, one of the hottest gaming companies in the U.S. (17 Jun 2019)

more »


Site feed Updated: 2019-Jun-19 15:00