tungwaiyip.info

home

about me

links

Blog

< November 2004 >
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930    

past articles »

Click for San Francisco, California Forecast

San Francisco, USA

 

Former Britannica Editor on Wikipedia

Former Britannica Editor Robert McHenry has an article on Wikipedia titled The Faith-Based Encyclopedia. I was hoping that he will make some valuable critique on the Wikipedia project. Unfortunately the article is mostly him trashing the Wikipedia, labeling it as faith-based (dictionary definition of faith: Belief that does not rest on logical proof or material evidence) and comparing using Wikipedia as going to public restroom. It is much like hearing Bill Gates dismissing Linux.

The one example he based his attack on is an article on Alexander Hamilton, especially an inaccuracy regarding the uncertainty of his birth year. To be honest I think he is just nitpicking on the two years difference. It may matter to an historian but to me I got fair amount of basic information despite this subtle issue. First lesson, in the age of information glut, critical reading is an essential skill. Not that I would trust Britannica or other professional journalist completely as they too are human who can make mistakes. Set you trust base on the background of the author. Expect error and disagreements.

So I went to Wikipedia to see the article for myself and I came out with quite different impression. The inaccuracy he raised is addressed by volunteers on the same day. I think he should be really impressed. Wikipedia also keep a list of mistakes in Britannica. I wonder how long it would take for them to be addressed. More interestingly this highlighted a new idea, that articles are no longer a static, completed work but always a work in progress.

Then I checked the change history. One thing I appreciate about Wiki is its transparency. Every change is commented. It shows active participation from multiple individuals. They maybe not be in full agreement, but they do know what they are talking about. It is not quite the sloppy image Robert tried to project.

Many editors also posted their profile. See a few of them who has contributed to this article

Taxman
I've been reading everything I could get my hands on since the age of 5...

Decumanus (Matthew Trump)
A U.S. physicist, computer consultant and ex-New Yorker...

R. fiend
I'm just a guy with too much free time on my hands...
(sounds self-deprecating for someone who has contributed over 50 articles)

These sounds like fairly intelligent individuals to me. And that's what so revolutionary about Wiki. It networks many bright people and facilitate them to work toward a common goal. Wikipedia is one great example of solid achievement.

As of Robert McHenry, I would said he is really behind times.

2004.11.17 comments

 

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

past articles »

 

BBC News

 

Delhi riots: 23 killed as Hindu and Muslim groups clash (26 Feb 2020)

 

Singer Duffy 'drugged, raped and held captive' (26 Feb 2020)

 

Sydney baboons go on the run before vasectomy (26 Feb 2020)

 

Appeal for more funds to control locusts (26 Feb 2020)

 

Weinstein's lawyer Donna Rotunno: 'The fight is not over' (26 Feb 2020)

 

White Helmets appeal for help from world powers in Syria's Idlib (26 Feb 2020)

 

Hong Kong to give cash gift of ,200 to residents (26 Feb 2020)

 

Mario Cerciello Rega: US students in court over police murder (26 Feb 2020)

 

Virgin Galactic sees demand for space travel surge (26 Feb 2020)

 

Outdoor heaters: Paris campaigners want them banned (26 Feb 2020)

more »

 

SF Gate

 

As the startup boom deflates, tech is humbled (24 Feb 2020)

 

Dow drops more than 1,000 as outbreak threatens the economy (24 Feb 2020)

 

Ship traffic, February 25 (24 Feb 2020)

 

Can AI flag disease outbreaks faster than humans? Not quite (23 Feb 2020)

 

Ship traffic, February 23 (22 Feb 2020)

 

Firms encouraged to shift strategy after startup stage (22 Feb 2020)

more »


Site feed Updated: 2020-Feb-26 03:00